Rockwell and Brinell are both widely used indentation hardness tests for metals, but they measure different things: the Brinell test measures the diameter of the indentation, the Rockwell test measures its depth. Most of the differences in specimen preparation, speed, sources of error and suitable materials follow from this.

Editions of the standards used

  • Brinell: ISO 6506-1:2014 Metallic materials — Brinell hardness test — Part 1: Test method (3rd edition; according to the ISO website it was reviewed and confirmed in 2025)
  • Rockwell: ISO 6508-1:2023 Metallic materials — Rockwell hardness test — Part 1: Test method (5th edition, replacing the 2016 edition)

Values are taken from the publicly available sample pages of these standards (foreword to the test-report clause). The annexes (for example the minimum-thickness tables) and the verification and calibration of testing machines (ISO 6506-2, ISO 6508-2) are not in the samples and are not cited here. For actual testing, follow the full text of the standard.

All numerical examples in this article are calculated from the formulas; they are not measured data.

1. Principles

Brinell hardness (ISO 6506-1:2014)

A hardmetal ball of diameter D is pressed into the test piece with a test force F. After the force is removed, the indentation diameter is measured in two approximately perpendicular directions and the arithmetic mean d is used to calculate:

HBW = 0.102 × 2F / ( π · D · ( D − √(D² − d²) ) )

F is in N, D and d in mm. The result is rounded to three significant figures.

  • Ball diameters are 10, 5, 2.5 and 1 mm; the standard recommends using the largest ball possible.
  • The test force is chosen by the force–diameter ratio 0.102F/D² (for example HBW 10/3000: ratio 30, test force 29 420 N) so that d lies between 0.24D and 0.6D. If it does not, d/D must be stated in the test report.
  • Tests are normally carried out between 10 °C and 35 °C. The time to reach the test force is 2 to 8 s, and the test force is held for 10 to 15 s.

Rockwell hardness (ISO 6508-1:2023)

Force is applied in two steps: first the preliminary test force F0, then the additional test force F1. After the total force F has been held, F1 is removed and the permanent depth of indentation h (mm) is measured while F0 is still applied. Hardness is:

Rockwell hardness = N − h / S
Scale Indenter Preliminary force F0 Total force F N S (mm) Range of application
HRA Diamond cone 98.07 N 588.4 N 100 0.002 20 to 95 HRA
HRBW Hardmetal ball 1.5875 mm 98.07 N 980.7 N 130 0.002 10 to 100 HRBW
HRC Diamond cone 98.07 N 1 471 N 100 0.002 20 to 70 HRC
HR15N / 30N / 45N Diamond cone 29.42 N 147.1 / 294.2 / 441.3 N 100 0.001 70–94 / 42–86 / 20–77
HR15TW / 30TW / 45TW Hardmetal ball 1.5875 mm 29.42 N 147.1 / 294.2 / 441.3 N 100 0.001 67–93 / 29–82 / 10–72

(Only some scales are listed. HRC can be extended to 10 HRC when the indenter meets specific conditions; see the standard. S = 0.002 mm means one Rockwell unit corresponds to 2 μm of depth.)

The W in the scale symbol stands for a tungsten carbide (hardmetal) ball. The current edition requires hardmetal balls; steel balls are allowed only for the HR15TSm and HR30TSm tests in Annex A. Earlier editions allowed steel balls, which is why older reports show "HRB" without the W, or symbols with an S.

How force is applied according to ISO 6508-1:2023:

  • the preliminary force is applied in no more than 2 s and held for 3 s (+1/−2 s);
  • for the regular scales, F1 is applied in 1 to 8 s; for the superficial scales (HRN, HRTW) in 4 s or less;
  • the total force is held for 5 s (+1/−3 s). If a material needs more than 6 s, the duration is stated in the report;
  • after F1 is removed, the reading is taken after 4 s (+1/−3 s) under F0.

Note: many online sources (and an earlier draft of this article) still quote timings from older editions, such as "total force held for 4 ± 2 s". Check the edition when you cite a value.

2. Worked calculations (not measurements)

The numbers below only illustrate the formulas; they are not results from any real test piece.

Brinell: HBW 10/3000 (D = 10 mm, F = 29 420 N) with a mean diameter d = 4.00 mm:

HBW = 0.102 × 2 × 29420 / ( π × 10 × ( 10 − √(100 − 16) ) ) ≈ 229

The indentation depth is then (D − √(D² − d²)) / 2 ≈ 0.42 mm.

If d is read 1% too large (4.04 mm), the result drops by about 2.1%. Across the 0.24D to 0.6D range, a 1% error in d corresponds to roughly a 2.0% to 2.2% error in hardness. This is why the Brinell test depends so much on accurate diameter measurement.

Rockwell: on the HRC scale with a permanent depth h = 0.080 mm, HRC = 100 − 0.080 / 0.002 = 60. Every 2 μm change in h changes the reading by 1 HRC.

3. Main differences

Aspect Brinell Rockwell
Quantity measured Indentation diameter (optical) Permanent indentation depth (measured by the machine)
How the result is obtained Calculated after measuring the diameter Displayed directly by the machine
Indentation size Relatively large (about 2.4 to 6 mm with a 10 mm ball) Relatively small
Sensitivity to inhomogeneous structure Large indentation area, so a value closer to the average Small indentation, more affected by local structure
Main sources of error Reading the diameter, illumination, judging the indentation edge Specimen support, surface condition, stability under the preliminary force
Speed and automation Optical measurement needed, slower; can be assisted by image systems Fast, suited to high-volume inspection

According to ZwickRoell's technical information, Brinell hardness is normally used for materials with large grain size, rough surfaces or inhomogeneous structure, such as castings and forgings. The Rockwell test needs no optical measurement and gives the result directly from depth, which makes it suitable for fast inspection of heat-treated parts on the shop floor.

4. Specimen thickness and indentation spacing

Requirement Brinell (ISO 6506-1:2014) Rockwell (ISO 6508-1:2023)
Minimum thickness At least 8 × the indentation depth At least 10 × the permanent depth for diamond indenters, 15 × for ball indenters (unless it can be shown that a thinner piece does not affect the result)
Distance between indentation centres At least 3 × the mean indentation diameter At least 3 × the indentation diameter
Centre to edge At least 2.5 × the mean indentation diameter At least 2.5 × the indentation diameter

With the worked calculations above, a Brinell depth of 0.42 mm needs a test piece at least about 3.4 mm thick, and an HRC permanent depth of 0.080 mm needs at least about 0.8 mm. Both standards have fuller minimum-thickness tables in their annexes.

5. How to choose

These questions help:

  1. Is the structure of the material uniform? For cast iron, coarse-grained and other inhomogeneous materials, the larger Brinell indentation is more representative.
  2. Is the specimen large and thick enough? Check thickness and spacing as in section 4. Thin sheet and small parts often allow only Rockwell or superficial Rockwell scales.
  3. Is a large indentation acceptable? Finished surfaces often cannot show a visible indentation.
  4. How quickly is the result needed? For high-volume inspection, the speed of the Rockwell test is a clear advantage.
  5. Which method does the specification or customer require? If a drawing, product standard or contract specifies the method and scale, follow it.

6. Hardness conversions are only a guide

ISO 18265 and ASTM E140 provide conversion tables between hardness scales and between hardness and tensile strength. When using them:

  • The tables are empirical relationships derived from comparison tests on particular materials, not physical laws.
  • The relationship depends on the material, its heat treatment and its processing condition; one table cannot be used for different materials.
  • A converted value does not replace a value measured with the specified method. If a specification asks for hardness on a particular scale, measure it with that method.
  • When reporting a converted value, state that it is converted and which standard and table were used.

7. Common misconceptions

  • "Brinell and Rockwell numbers can be compared directly." Their units and definitions are completely different.
  • "A higher Rockwell number means harder, so different scales can be compared." HRBW and HRC use different indenters and forces; their numbers are not comparable.
  • "Automating the Brinell test with image measurement automatically makes it more accurate." Image measurement reduces operator differences but amplifies calibration errors: a 1% error in the diameter is roughly a 2% error in hardness (see section 2). See the article "Measuring Brinell indentation diameters with OpenCV" on this site.

8. Scope and limitations of this article

  • This article compares the principles of the two tests and how to choose between them. It does not replace the standards and does not cover verification and calibration of machines and indenters (ISO 6506-2, ISO 6508-2).
  • Ranges and timings come from the public sample pages of the standards; check them against the full text of the edition you use. ASTM E10 (Brinell) and ASTM E18 (Rockwell) do not match ISO in every detail.
  • The numbers in section 2 are worked calculations and are not typical hardness values of any material.